The 2024-25 NFL Rookie of the Year odds offer good opportunities for gamblers who follow the fresh talent that comes into the league every season. Don’t worry if you don’t belong in that category, because I’m here to help you beat the best NFL betting sites.
In this guide, I analyze the best offensive and defensive rookie prospects entering the NFL this season. The prices have been updated after three weeks of action, and there are some notable changes to analyze. I break down the top contenders in the NFL ROY odds, both for defensive and offensive rookie, before sharing my predictions.
NFL Rookie of the Year Odds for 2024-25
The latest NFL Rookie of the Year betting odds allow you to bet on players from both sides of the ball. Here are the current Rookie of the Year odds for the top offensive and defensive players, courtesy of Bovada sportsbook.
Offensive Rookie of the Year Odds
| OFFENSIVE ROOKIE | LATEST ROOKIE OF THE YEAR ODDS | PREVIOUS ODDS |
|---|---|---|
| Jayden Daniels (WSH) | -125 | -250 |
| Caleb Williams (CHI) | +110 | +300 |
| Malik Nabers (NYG) | +1500 | +700 |
| Brian Thomas (JAC) | +2000 | +5000 |
| Brock Bowers (LV) | +2000 | +6000 |
| Drake Maye (NE) | +4000 | +4000 |
| Bo Nix (DEN) | +4500 | +2500 |
| Marvin Harrison Jr. (ARI) | +5000 | +1600 |
Commanders’ QB Jayden Daniels (-125) continues to lead the way in the NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year odds. However, his gap at the top of the board has gotten smaller.
Currently, Daniels has a 55.6% implied probability of winning the prestigious rookie award. After leading the Commanders to a 4-2 record and the top of the NFC East, Daniels dropped to -250 from +140. However, the former LSU star was injured early in Washington’s 40-7 rout over Carolina.
Meanwhile, Malik Nabers (+1500) and Marvin Harrison Jr. (+5000) have seen their NFL 2024-25 Rookie of the Year betting odds plummet. Nabers recently returned from a concussion, while Harrison Jr. suffered the same injury.
Meanwhile, #1 pick Caleb Williams (+300) is closing in on Daniels after the Bears’ bye week! If Daniels can return from his rib injury, Daniels vs. Williams could be the headline of NFL Week 8 action as the Commanders host the Bears on Sunday afternoon in a prime TV slot.
Defensive Rookie of the Year Odds
| DEFENSIVE ROOKIE | LATEST ROOKIE OF THE YEAR ODDS | PREVIOUS ODDS |
|---|---|---|
| Jared Verse (LAR) | +115 | +210 |
| Laiatu Latu (IND) | +650 | +475 |
| Quinyon Mitchell (PHI) | +750 | +1200 |
| Calen Bullock (HOU) | +1200 | N/A |
| Evan Williams (GB) | +1400 | N/A |
| Byron Murphy (SEA) | +1500 | +1200 |
| Kamari Lassiter (HOU) | +1800 | +600 |
| Braden Fiske (LAR) | +2200 | N/A |
| Edgerrin Cooper (GB) | +2200 | N/A |
Rams’ linebacker Jared Verse (+275) has seen his odds shorten even more at NFL football betting sites. After a promising Week 1 performance, Verse’s price saw a jolt in the NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year betting markets. The former Florida State star continues to lead the way.
He remains the favorite, and his price shortened from +210 to +115! Verse had +1000 odds to win 2024-25 NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year in the preseason.
Laiatu Latu (+650) still has the second-best DROY odds, and his price has dropped slightly from +475 to +650. Verse has established a even larger gap between himself and the rest of the top contenders in the NFL.
Heading into NFL Week 8 action, four players have risen up the board. Houston’s Calen Bullock (+1200), Green Bay’s Evan Williams (+1400) and Edgerrin Cooper (+2200), and Verse’s Rams’ teammate, Braden Fiske (+2200) all now offer realistic value at NFL betting sites.
Updated 2024-25 Offensive Rookie of the Year Odds
Jayden Daniels is still leading the field at offshore sportsbooks. Let’s delve into the updated 2024-25 NFL Rookie of the Year odds:
Jayden Daniels (-250)
Jayden Daniels continues stake his claim as the best offensive rookie in the NFL this season! The former LSU star has completed 75.6% of his passes for 1,410 yards, six touchdowns, and two interceptions. Daniels has also rushed 66 times for 372 yards and four scores!
Jayden Daniels is the only QB in NFL History with:
– 75% Completion Percentage
– 200 Pass Yards per Game
– 50 Rush Yards per Gamein any 7-game span.
And he has the Commanders in 1st Place at 5-2.
Rookie or not, that is MVP worthy at the moment.
Plenty more ball to play… https://t.co/ltI1KmJETI
— JJ Watt (@JJWatt) October 23, 2024
Daniels is having a phenomenal rookie season. However, his rib injury isn’t helping his NFL Rookie of the Year odds. The Commanders are going to be careful with Daniels, even though the world wants to see Daniels and Williams go head-to-head in Week 8. He is the future of their franchise, and it wouldn’t be wise to risk him for one game, especially since veteran Marcus Mariota played well, albeit against a terrible Carolina team.
However, if Daniels misses this game, and Williams lights up the Commanders, keep an eye on the top of the odds board as we could see a change at #1!
Caleb Williams (+300)
As the #1 pick, Caleb Williams was always going to be the preseason favorite in the NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year odds. But Williams got off to a bad start, throwing for only 93 yards in a 24-17 win over Tennessee in Week 1, and then 174 yards in a 19-13 loss in Houston. The former USC star didn’t even throw a touchdown over his first two weeks!
Caleb Williams was voted as the London Games MVP 👑 pic.twitter.com/gVWbg3GfvD
— Ficky (@itsfickybaby) October 25, 2024
But Williams got going in Week 3, passing for 363 yards, two touchdowns, and a pair of picks in a loss at Indianapolis. In Week 5, Williams gashed Carolina for 304 yards, two scores, and no interceptions in a 36-10 win!
Williams followed that up with a four-touchdown passing performance in a 35-16 win over Jacksonville in London, which led to the Bears’ bye week. The former USC star would love to face Daniels in a meeting of the two most recent Heisman winners!
Malik Nabers (+700)
Malik Nabers has slipped in the Offensive Rookie of the Year odds at offshore sportsbooks, but that’s only due to injury. Nabers, who was Daniels’ favorite target at LSU, suffered a concussion and missed two games.
LEEEEEK pic.twitter.com/BhhHvpD2iK
— New York Giants (@Giants) October 20, 2024
Nabers is 14th in the NFL in receiving yards with 427 yards, and he has added three touchdowns. His 60 targets is sixth in the league, so Daniel Jones will look for him when he returns. However, Jones has been inconsistent, at best.
The 21-year-old has plenty of time to get back to his past form, and move up the boards at NFL betting sites. Nabers’ odds do offer value, but he’s highly dependent on his quarterback to get him the ball accurately.
Marvin Harrison Jr. (+1600)
With Marvin Harrison Jr. struggling mightily in Arizona, Jacksonville’s Brian Thomas Jr. has taken his place in the NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year odds. Thomas Jr. was second to Nabers in receptions and yards at LSU, but he led the team with 17 touchdowns!
Brian Thomas Jr. might be the BIGGEST steal of the entire Draft. #Jaguars #Jags pic.twitter.com/04Egs4I2rf
— Clay Harbor (@clayharbs82) October 24, 2024
Thomas Jr. has carried that over to the pros as he leads the Jaguars in receptions (30), targets (45), yards (513), and touchdowns (4). It has been a difficult season for the 2-5 Jaguars, but Thomas Jr. has been a big bright spot. Their record is a hinderance to his chances, but the 22-year-old deserves some love in these odds!
Updated 2024-25 Defensive Rookie of the Year Odds
The odds for this season’s Defensive Rookie of the Year have not changed much recently. Rams’ pass rusher Jared Verge has emerged as the favorite after a strong start to the season, and increasing his lead.
Jared Verse (+115)
Verse is starting to run away in the NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year odds at Bovada! The former Florida State standout linebacker had a fantastic game in Week 8’s 30-20 win over Minnesota. Verse had three tackles, along with 1.5 sacks.
Rams rookie DE Jared Verse, after his second straight outstanding performance (1.5 sacks; 4 QB hits): “When they get tired, I’m not gonna get tired. I’m gonna keep talking, I’m gonna keep being loud, they’re gonna get more tired. They’re gonna fall down.” – per @JourdanRodrigue pic.twitter.com/GQle0pcOc3
— Peter Schrager (@PSchrags) October 25, 2024
The Rams’ offense is getting healthier. If they can get leads, that gives Verse more chances to rush the quarterback as teams will have to chase Los Angeles. Verse has 2.5 sacks, which leads all rookies, and that will give him the edge heading into the second half of the season.
Laiatu Latu (+650)
Colts’ defensive lineman Laiatu Latu’s rookie DPOY odds have moved slightly from +475 to +650, and he is still in the mix for this award.
JC Latham vs Laiatu Latu is going to be a matchup to keep your eyes on this weekend 👀 pic.twitter.com/AHsAjMyzSn
— AtoZ Sports Nashville (@AtoZSports) October 8, 2024
Latu is also coming off a good game as the Colts beat Miami 16-10, and the former UCLA product had three tackles (two solo) and a sack. His two sacks are second to Verse among rookie NFL defenders!
Latu was the first defensive player selected in the draft at the 15th pick, and won the Pac-12 Defensive Player of the Year, leading the conference with 13.0 sacks. The 23-year-old just needs more opportunities to rush the quarterback, and he could overtake Verse on the board. He has to take his game to another level, however, and quickly!
Quinyon Mitchell (+750)
Quinyon Mitchell is making moves up the NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year odds! The first-year cornerback has been brilliant this season, posting 24 tackles, although he has yet to make an interception.
Quinyon Mitchell vs. Malik Nabers. pic.twitter.com/dpvFNQcBGS
— Victor Williams (@ThePhillyPod) October 20, 2024
The Eagles drafted Mitchell in the first round out of Toledo, and he has slotted in seamlessly alongside #1 corner Darius Slay Jr. If Mitchell can pick up a few interceptions throughout the season, he has a great chance to move up the board at Bovada!
Dallas Turner (+1000)
Calen Bullock, on the other hand, has three intereceptions this season for the Houston Texans, and the safety also has 20 tackles!
#Texans safety Calen Bullock — Cover 1 single-high
Bullock has the skillset to become one of the best center fielders in the NFL. High football IQ and terrific ball skills. pic.twitter.com/xv9VEzr4fB
— Kendell Hollowell (@KHollowell_) October 23, 2024
The Texans trust Bullock to be in single-high coverage and make the right decision, as shown above. He has fantastic ball skills, and has been overwhelmed by joining an already-good defensive unit. The first-year product out of USC might have the highest upside of anyone in these NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year odds!
Rookie of the Year Predictions for the 2024-2025 Season
There are hundreds of rookies entering the league this year, but only two can claim the Rookie of the Year awards. Historically, quarterbacks and pass rushers have been favored in the OROY and DROY races, respectively.
Offensive Rookie of the Year Best Bet
Williams is catching up to the speed of the NFL game, and his NFL Rookie of the Year odds have bounced back. However, right now, this is Jayden Daniels’ award to lose.
Daniels has already proven he can handle and adjust to the pro game in a hurry. However, I’ll have a close eye on this week’s game with the Bears, especially if Daniels doesn’t play. If he is absent, Williams has a massive chance to take his place!
At plus odds to win the 2024-25 OPOY, Daniels was a pretty strong bargain bet. At -125, he is still a good pick.
As Daniels grows, the Commanders will be a sharp pick in The Sports Geek free NFL pick’em contest to win great prizes!
Defensive Rookie of the Year Best Bet
On the defensive side, I originally thought Chop Robinson was going to be the DROY winner.
It is a small sample size, but Robinson has not impressed as much as other defensive rookies so far this preseason. Verse has been impressive, though, and he is in a great spot to produce in LA now that Aaron Donald is retired.
I was able to jump on Verse at +1000 odds earlier this month, so I certainly like where the bet stands now. Down to +115 at Bovada, Verse’s odds of NFL Defensive Player of the Year are still worth a shot! However, I’ll also have an eye on Calen Bullock in Houston if he keep grabbing interceptions.
